In our first post of this three-part series — “LinkedIn Without a Photo? Think Again.” — we looked at why skipping a headshot might actually be hurting your professional presence more than helping it.
But here’s the thing: just having a photo isn’t always enough. In fact, the wrong photo can quietly send the wrong message, and it might be costing you credibility without you even realizing it.
In this second post, we’re digging into the subtle red flags a LinkedIn photo can send, and how to make sure yours is working for you, not against you.
1. The “Too Casual” Trap
Yes, you want to look approachable, but there’s a fine line between relaxed and unprepared.
Beach photos, car selfies, bar shots… they might look “real,” but they don’t say “ready for business.”
2. Overly Staged or Outdated
That overly retouched studio shot from 2011? It’s giving “catfishing energy.” If your current self walks into a room and people don’t recognize you from LinkedIn, it’s time for a refresh.
3. Bad Lighting, Busy Backgrounds, Poor Cropping
These aren’t just cosmetic. They tell people something about your attention to detail. Inconsistent quality can feel like inconsistent professionalism, even if you’re actually top of your game.
4. Expressions That Miss the Mark
Looking confident is great. But resting boss-face? Not so much.
On the flip side, looking too smiley might come across as unsure. You want balance: open, grounded, real.
So What’s the Fix?
The goal is a photo that feels like you on your best day, confident, polished, and clear about what you bring to the table.
Professional headshots help you get there. Not by making you look artificial, but by helping you show up with intention.
Want to see the difference for yourself?
Check out our gallery to see how the right light, angle, and expression can transform your online presence.
Ready to plan your session? Contact us today.
P.S.: Follow us on Instagram, LinkedIn, and Facebook
Co-owner of Headshots NYC, Deutsch Photography & Gotham Family Photos. Lover of images & the stories they tell. Fanatic about words, numbers & patterns. Entrepreneur & adventurer w/keen wanderlust. Life/love/business partner of my husband, photographer Brett Deutsch. Eternal love affair with NYC, where I landed by way of GA, TX & CA.
